View Post

The Accountability Dilemma: Civilian Cyber Vigilantism and International Law

Joanna Kulesza & Francesca Mazzonelli Opinions

How can we address the accountability of civilian hackers and cyber mercenaries in modern conflicts? The rise of volunteer cyber participants in the Ukrainian conflict reveals significant gaps in the legal and ethical standards. This opinion piece argues that existing international laws are inadequate for managing the complex roles of these actors and calls for urgent reform. By examining the …

View Post

Limiting Internet Blackouts Crucial to Peace and Security in Africa

Nnenna Ifeanyi-Ajufo Opinions

Defining a firm framework on internet access during conflicts should become an important agenda to finding answers to the challenges of peace and security in Africa. The region continues to face several armed conflicts and waves of military coups. If the African Union is to meet its aspiration to ‘Silence the Guns,’ then, citizens’ rights to internet during conflicts should …

View Post

How African States Can Promote the Common African Position on the Applicability of International Law in the OEWG

Moliehi Makumane Opinions

African member states have made up approximately 30% of speakers during the substantive sessions of the Open-Ended Working Group on Security of and in the Use of Information and Communication Technologies (OEWG). African states are also among those most vulnerable to malicious ICT activities, which have potential to affect some of the region’s biggest economies. In a 2023 ranking of …

View Post

Resilient Connectivity: SpaceX’s Stellar Solution for Gaza’s Internet Amid Conflict

Joanna Kulesza Research Bites

Recent high-profile international incidents are shedding light on the political, legal and technical limitations associated with the use of Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellite constellations for broadband Internet services. In a noteworthy development, the leading provider of this technology, SpaceX’s Starlink, has reached a mutual understanding with Israel to refrain from extending its services to Israel and the occupied territories, …

View Post

Ukraine Cyber War One Year On: An International Law Case Study

Joanna Kulesza Commentary

Russia committed a grave violation of international law when it invaded Ukraine one year ago. Russia and Ukraine are at war, but are they also at cyber war? We have seamlessly passed the much-debated Article 51 UNC threshold and moved into a cyber warzone, where shelling of Ukrainian towns and villages is accompanied by cyberattacks on its allies’ critical infrastructure. …

View Post

Satellite Internet Access in Times of Cyber Conflict

Berna Akcali Gur Commentary

On 26 February 2022, two days after the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Elon Musk, SpaceX founder and CEO, responded to a request from the Ukrainian deputy prime minister, confirming on Twitter that Starlink satellite internet service is active in Ukraine. A technology that had thus far been considered an experimental alternative to undersea and on-the-ground telecommunication services suddenly became the …

View Post

Russia’s Vision for a Cybercrime Treaty

Joyce Hakmeh Commentary

In January 2022, the UN will hold the first meeting to negotiate a treaty on cybercrime. While most states are in the process of developing their positions around the scope and the principles of this new treaty, Russia has already submitted a draft proposal to the UN suggesting it to be used as the basis of the negotiations. This draft …

View Post

Cyber Norms: Specialisation from Fragmentation?

Evan Burke Commentary

What are the ‘rules of the road’ for cyberspace, and who sets them? The question has risen in prominence and priority as cyber threats have grown more severe. A lack of clarity about acceptable behaviour enables destabilising cyber activity, such as the recent Microsoft Exchange hack by suspected state-sponsored actors and the persistent ransomware attacks targeting hospitals around the world. …

View Post

The ‘Invisible’ International Law in Cyberspace

Joanna Kulesza Opinions

Recent state contributions to the discussion of how international law applies in cyberspace suggest that the cybersecurity dialect of international law is losing sight of the mainstream – that is, how international law is applied outside of the cyber bubble. The fact that states contest certain rules and standards of international conduct when it suits their current interests and ambitions …

View Post

Navigating a Finnish Take on International Law

Eneken Tikk Interviews

If you’re talking about international law and cyberspace, it’s hard to find a better person to talk to than Ambassador Marja Lehto, who wrote the recent Finnish position paper on the issue. A renowned international lawyer, Dr Lehto served as the Finnish expert in the tense 2016-2017 UN GGE. In 2016, she was elected to the International Law Commission of the UN (ILC) for the term of 2017-2021 with 175 votes, the highest vote total of the entire election.